Why David Mamet’s ‘The Edge’ Trumps Other Action Adventure Films
I was in graduate school when I chanced upon a copy of “The Edge” at my local Blockbuster.
It caught my eye because Anthony Hopkins is one of my favorite actors and while Alec Baldwin is a jerk in real life, he’s something of an actor. I didn’t notice (and this is important after the fact) that it was written by David Mamet. I’m not usually one for buddy films in the wilderness, but like a good adventure, so I took a chance on it.
I watched it after my wife and kids had gone to bed and then, the next day, watched it immediately again after tending to my morning duties, asking in my head, “Why the hell do I like this film so much?”
Then I noticed David Mamet’s name attached as the writer. That surprised me momentarily but then didn’t—I realized that the dialog had totally enthralled me. The “talk” in the film is as important as the action. This was, I realized, a very smart movie.
Some decades later, I would come across a confession by Mamet that confirmed my insights regarding this particular film. In 2008 he published this, voluntarily—“Why I am No Longer a Brain Dead Liberal in the Village Voice.
I’m not the first to notice this.
Obviously, back in the mid 1990s, Mamet had had some thoughts.
But to what makes this film so good. Doubtless, this reading audience is familiar with Liam Neeson’s turn in “The Grey,” As good as “The Grey” is, and it is good, “The Edge” is better.
Both films traffic in rather complicated intellectual and emotional landscapes—that are masqueraded by the natural landscapes of the actions of their plots. But “The Edge,” directed by Lee Tamahori, more securely connects that physical environment to the emotional and psychological and philosophical (which, this latter, “The Grey” lacks, though it strains admirably for a poetic one) grounds that give meaning to the basic physical adventures depicted.
It is one thing for a man to face a life-and-death situation that asks him to question (privately) every decision he has ever made. It is another for a life-and-death situation to ask a man to question the very basis of reality itself. “The Edge” asks its protagonist, Charles Morse, to do this; “The Grey” asks its protagonist to face the question, but shies from solving that dilemma.
“The Edge” is too smart to be explicit in this regard. But the questions it asks challenge the viewer to wonder about his or her own assumptions about, well, everything.
In movie review mode, I would offer you a non-spoiler description: A suspicious billionaire becomes trapped in the wilderness with the suspected paramour of his super model wife and must discover if he has what it takes to survive with a partner by whom he’s being cuckolded and suspects of trying to kill him—even while he’s being hunted by a man-eating Kodiak Bear.
But there is so much more to the film.
It begins (and pay attention to the musical score, by Jerry Goldsmith, a rich symphonic background that combines the possible heights of human aspiration and the sadness of the tragedies that attend human existence) with a shot of the tail section of a plane.
This segues to an establishing shot that shows a group of people exited a midsize airplane. This leads to a shot of Charles Morse (Hopkins) isolating himself from the others and walking into what is a regional hangar, to have a short conversation with a mechanic.
So—Charles Morse, a billionaire, is established as the “isolato”: the “isolated man.” He is a man apart. Different from others. American audiences can be forgiven for believing that he’s a man isolated by luck.
But Mamet dispels this belief in a brief conversation between Charles and Bob Green (Baldwin) in the airplane before the “crisis” of the film (a foreshadowed “bird-strike” that brings the plane disastrously into a lake in the middle of nowhere and kills the pilot, leaving Charles, Bob, and Stephen (Harold Perrineau) alone in the wilderness trying to figure out how to survive).
Just before this “inciting action,” Bob (who is having an affair with Charles’ wife, “Mickey” (Elle MacPherson), he says, “I admire the way you took that joke last night.” Charles says, “Thank you.” “Tough row to hoe, if you think about it.” “What would that be?” “All that money…Never knowing who your friends are. Never knowing what people value you for…”Yeah…” “Must be tough.” “Never feel sorry for a man who owns a plane.”
“Tough row to hoe” is a slavery expression—it’s an expression of a person who believes that the system is designed to enslave people to their appointed lots. It’s a philosophical belief that human beings are incapable of changing the “arc” of their own destinies.
RELATED: The Real Reason ‘The Exorcist’ Remains Iconic
Charles’ response is a rebellion against such thinking—he says, “Never feel sorry for a man who owns a plane.” Why? Because the only people who own planes are people who set out to own their own planes. It does not happen by accident.
Here, Charles expresses that any human being in his position is responsible for everything that happens to him. Bob expresses or espouses a philosophy that says that human suffering is meaningless; that humans are subject to forces over which they have no control and must negotiate not a benign universe (never mind a benevolent one) but a malevolent one (Melville’s dilemma, I think) and hopelessly hope for the best.
But as the film plays out, Mamet charts a course. Charles is established as the protagonist and the isolated man (for reasons we do not know). The party (city mouse/country mouse faerie tale) is introduced by the lodge owner (L.Q. Jones, as John Styles) to the differences in life between their experiences and what it’s like in the wilderness.
Charles proves himself, in a bookish way, knowledgeable of such differences, but confesses that his knowledge has never really been tested). The lodge owner loses a bet and acknowledges that Charles might hold valuable knowledge as the result of an honored lost bet between the two men.
After the main characters find themselves lost in the wilderness, they come (well, Charles does) what the lodge owner meant in his warning about bears: “If you see one, stand real still. Let him know that you know that he sees ya. Then, back up reeeal slow. Anybody in trouble, get my attention. I’ll be on it like a duck on a June bug.”
We do not know how valuable this advice is until the main characters are confronted by the Bear after the plane crash. Charles is the only character who responds according to the lodge owner’s advice. He stands still and makes sure the Bear knows he (Charles) sees him.
Why? Because the humans are no longer in “human” (city) world; they are in “Bear World.”
In short, the lodge owner taught them how to respond to a bear as a bear. No bear wants to fight another bear. When a beta bear meets an alpha, he does what the lodge owner describes. He stands still. He makes sure the alpha knows the beta knows that the alpha sees him.
Then, he backs up, reeeal slow.
RELATED: Must-Read Movie Books for Your Library
Of course, on the day the beta thinks he can become the alpha, he will behave differently. But, until that day, the beta will behave as the beta. John Styles’ advise to the city folks in this situation is to assume they are beta.
Why? Because all of the characters in the film are in bear country; they are not in “man” country. Period. Charles is the only character who seems to appreciate this—but not totally. For much of the film, he thinks “escaping” their situation is the way to survival; but confronting it in every way is the way to survival.
Perhaps needless to say, the film leads us to a moment of this realization. And it’s quite satisfying, even as it traffics in the tragedy of bad decisions and selfishness. Charles finally learns his lesson (which is what the film is really about)—but so does Bob Green. And that is a satisfaction quite un-looked for.
In the end (and from the beginning) “The Edge” (which was originally called by Mamet, “The Bookworm,” which I would have gone to the theater to see but perhaps no one else would have), bravely offers a story that introduces three themes: man v. himself; man v. man; and man v. nature.
The film ingeniously resolves those themes in the opposite order—as if to say, “You cannot fix your broken relationship with yourself without first fixing your relationship with your fellow man which, as it turns out, you cannot fix without figuring out why your relationship with Nature (God, obviously) is so messed up.
Confront the sacred Bear; Confront the sacred Man; Confront the sacred Self.
Well worth your time—both in terms of a conventional adventure film, an “anti” buddy film, and a philosophic mining of human existence film whose double dialog will keep you guessing the entire time.
No spoiler here—but the question for the protagonist is whether he will learn the lessons offered to him by his experience. Teaser: Bob Green (Alec Baldwin’s character) definitely learns those lessons first.
Spoilers ahead (now):
Mamet originally ended the film by having Charles Morse refuse to be saved. The rescue helicopter appears, Bob dies, and Charles walks into the woods, alone, never to be seen again.
So glad the film ends the way it does.
In a seminal moment early in the film, Charles says, “I read something interesting in a book one time. Do you know why people die in the woods? They die of shame. …They ask themselves this question: What did I do wrong that I don’t know what to do now? And they sit down…they give up…and they die.”
If Charles Morse had exited as Mamet had him in the script, to live out his life in the wilderness and he’d lived to old age and then died, alone but on his own terms, what would he have died of?
Shame.
Gregory Borse teaches film appreciation, history & development, philosophy, literary theory and a variety of literatures on a small campus in a large university system in the South. His short story “Joyellen” was selected as an online exclusive for West Trade Review’s Summer 2021 issue. He has published or presented in the past on Hitchcock’s “Psycho,” Stephen Frear’s “The Grifters” and seminal horror films ranging from “Nosferatu” to “Halloween,” “The Silence of the Lambs” and “The Strangers,” among others.
purchase fenofibrate generic buy fenofibrate tablets brand tricor
ketotifen 1 mg uk doxepin online buy generic tofranil
acarbose price buy acarbose generic order griseofulvin 250 mg online cheap
order generic dipyridamole 100mg generic plendil purchase pravastatin generic
florinef 100 mcg usa buy imodium cheap imodium us
buy etodolac 600 mg generic pletal 100mg without prescription order cilostazol 100mg pills
buy prasugrel without a prescription thorazine 100mg ca buy tolterodine for sale
buy ferrous 100mg pills buy betapace 40mg pills order betapace 40mg sale
buy pyridostigmine 60 mg generic piroxicam 20mg pills order rizatriptan
buy cheap generic vasotec cost lactulose duphalac over the counter
oral xalatan exelon pills generic rivastigmine 6mg
betahistine 16mg for sale probalan online buy where can i buy probalan
prilosec 20mg oral order omeprazole 20mg for sale buy metoprolol for sale
order telmisartan 80mg for sale plaquenil brand molnupiravir pills
cialis 10mg without prescription generic sildenafil 100mg purchase sildenafil
buy cenforce 50mg without prescription order cenforce sale buy chloroquine generic
buy provigil online cheap deltasone 20mg pills prednisone medication
buy cefdinir generic metformin 1000mg cost prevacid 15mg sale
where can i buy atorvastatin buy albuterol 100 mcg amlodipine online order
pantoprazole tablet lisinopril 5mg tablet pyridium ca
order symmetrel 100 mg without prescription buy dapsone 100 mg for sale oral aczone
medrol 16 mg for sale order generic adalat buy aristocort generic
perindopril over the counter fexofenadine 120mg us fexofenadine 180mg cost
buy lioresal purchase ozobax without prescription order toradol 10mg pills
alendronate where to buy brand gloperba buy nitrofurantoin 100 mg sale
amaryl online order buy generic etoricoxib online buy arcoxia paypal
order orlistat without prescription where can i buy diltiazem buy generic diltiazem
famotidine 40mg brand buy tacrolimus 5mg sale buy prograf generic
order azelastine 10ml online cheap avapro 150mg uk oral irbesartan 300mg
order zyloprim 100mg online cheap rosuvastatin 10mg oral cheap rosuvastatin 20mg
buy buspirone 5mg online purchase buspar without prescription oral amiodarone
cost domperidone buy domperidone online buy tetracycline 250mg pills
buy lamotrigine generic order vermox pill purchase mebendazole without prescription
buy tretinoin paypal avanafil ca avanafil medication
purchase tadacip online buy tadacip generic buy indomethacin 50mg pill
order lamisil pills slot machine games casino online games for real money
order an essay online college essay grader order suprax 200mg online cheap
buy amoxicillin medication amoxicillin 250mg over the counter order biaxin 500mg pill
catapres 0.1 mg uk spiriva 9mcg for sale oral spiriva 9mcg
generic minocin 50mg buy requip paypal buy ropinirole 2mg generic
buy letrozole order albendazole online cheap aripiprazole 30mg without prescription
order medroxyprogesterone for sale how to buy praziquantel buy hydrochlorothiazide 25mg online
buy duloxetine 20mg pill provigil 200mg canada modafinil online buy
cost promethazine 25mg over the counter ed pills ivermectin dosage
prednisone 5mg ca order generic deltasone 5mg amoxicillin 500mg cheap
generic furosemide 100mg order doxycycline 100mg without prescription order albuterol 2mg online
augmentin uk buy generic augmentin 375mg buy cheap generic clomiphene
order combivent pill buy dexamethasone generic order zyvox generic
buy vardenafil 20mg generic hydroxychloroquine oral oral hydroxychloroquine
buy cenforce tablets aralen cost glucophage sale
order lipitor 40mg pills lipitor generic zestril 2.5mg ca
buy dostinex generic buy priligy 90mg online buy cheap generic priligy
medrol 8mg tablet order aristocort 4mg pills buy generic clarinex online
purchase cytotec without prescription purchase orlistat for sale order generic diltiazem 180mg
order nootropil 800mg pill piracetam online buy clomipramine 25mg drug
zovirax for sale online acyclovir 400mg ca oral crestor
buy generic itraconazole order tindamax 500mg pills buy tinidazole 500mg generic
buy cheap generic ezetimibe order domperidone 10mg generic buy sumycin 500mg generic
olanzapine 10mg tablet order olanzapine 10mg pills order valsartan 80mg pill
order generic cyclobenzaprine buy baclofen 10mg for sale order toradol online cheap
colcrys cost order generic clopidogrel 75mg buy methotrexate pill
prescription strength acne medication buy prednisolone sale best pills to treat acne
different types of allergy medicine advair diskus inhalator us allergy pills for rash
anti nausea medication from pharmacy generic lincocin
buy sleeping tablets uk online order provigil online
prednisone medication purchase prednisone sale
prescription heartburn medicine names antacid over the counter
acne treatment recommended by dermatologists buy generic eurax acne treatments that work uk
prescription heartburn medication side effects buy coversyl 8mg online cheap
cost isotretinoin 10mg cheap accutane 20mg order accutane 10mg for sale
buy sleeping tablets uk online oral modafinil
amoxicillin 1000mg without prescription amoxicillin 1000mg pills buy amoxil for sale
order azithromycin pill buy azithromycin pill zithromax 250mg tablet
generic gabapentin 100mg neurontin 600mg canada
azipro 500mg uk purchase azipro sale buy azipro pills
lasix 40mg cheap oral furosemide
order prednisolone generic omnacortil 20mg pills omnacortil 5mg sale
deltasone cost buy prednisone 40mg pill
amoxicillin us buy amoxil pills buy amoxil 500mg sale
vibra-tabs cheap doxycycline 200mg usa
buy antihistamine pills onlin albuterol online purchase ventolin generic
amoxiclav sale order augmentin 375mg sale
synthroid 100mcg cost buy levoxyl pills synthroid over the counter
vardenafil 20mg price order levitra 10mg
oral clomiphene 100mg order clomid 100mg clomiphene price
buy tizanidine online zanaflex pills buy zanaflex paypal
brand semaglutide 14mg purchase semaglutide buy rybelsus 14 mg
generic prednisone 40mg buy prednisone pills brand prednisone 5mg
order rybelsus 14 mg buy rybelsus for sale buy rybelsus generic
isotretinoin 10mg generic buy accutane without prescription buy accutane 40mg generic
cheap amoxil amoxicillin 1000mg us order amoxicillin 1000mg pill
buy ventolin 2mg without prescription purchase albuterol generic ventolin inhalator medication
azithromycin 250mg cost purchase zithromax for sale generic zithromax
amoxiclav order online buy clavulanate generic augmentin 625mg
prednisolone over the counter generic prednisolone 40mg oral omnacortil 10mg
order synthroid 150mcg pills buy synthroid 150mcg levoxyl price
neurontin 800mg uk buy gabapentin 800mg pills order neurontin 100mg for sale
furosemide pills buy lasix 100mg online oral furosemide 40mg
sildenafil 100mg price generic viagra 100mg sildenafil ca
buy monodox sale buy acticlate pill order monodox pill
jackpot party casino roulette wheel online where can i play poker online
pregabalin 75mg generic buy lyrica 150mg sale order lyrica for sale
buy cheap zithromax
triamcinolone 4mg canada order triamcinolone triamcinolone 10mg pill
desloratadine buy online buy clarinex medication purchase desloratadine pill
cialis 5mg us tadalafil 5mg oral buy cialis pills
buy cenforce 50mg online cheap order cenforce online cheap buy cenforce no prescription
buy generic claritin 10mg loratadine usa oral loratadine
jardiance vs metformin
chloroquine tablet buy chloroquine paypal purchase chloroquine online
cost priligy 30mg order dapoxetine 30mg pills order generic misoprostol
order xenical 120mg sale orlistat oral buy diltiazem 180mg for sale
uses for flagyl in humans
lisinopril kidney damage
can you take melatonin with zoloft
acyclovir 400mg usa acyclovir 800mg for sale order zyloprim 100mg
when should furosemide be taken
norvasc generic norvasc 5mg pill how to get norvasc without a prescription
zithromax single dose
gabapentin schedule
glucophage titration
order generic crestor order generic crestor zetia 10mg drug
how long does it take for lasix to work on edema
buy zestril 10mg for sale cheap lisinopril 10mg buy zestril 5mg
motilium 10mg tablet order generic domperidone 10mg buy tetracycline cheap
cephalexin dose for bv
buy amoxicillin
prilosec cost treat stomach buy omeprazole 10mg online cheap
escitalopram for pe
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg pill flexeril 15mg price baclofen 10mg price
gabapentin liquid for dogs
lopressor 100mg usa order metoprolol 50mg online cheap metoprolol 100mg brand
septra vs bactrim
ciprofloxacin and dexamethasone
cost ketorolac brand colchicine buy colchicine 0.5mg generic
what painkillers can i take with cephalexin
order tenormin 100mg for sale order atenolol atenolol pills
depo-medrol brand name medrol 8 mg without prescription how to buy medrol
academic writers online essays for sale online essays help
methotrexate 2.5mg generic buy coumadin medication medex online order
can cephalexin be used for sinus infection
is 3000 mg of amoxicillin a day too much
bactrim dosage for dogs
order maxolon online cheap reglan buy online order cozaar 25mg generic
meloxicam 7.5mg tablet celebrex 200mg generic buy generic celecoxib online
nexium sale buy nexium paypal brand topiramate
medications escitalopram
order generic flomax 0.4mg celecoxib 200mg usa celecoxib 200mg for sale
neurontin dose for adults
buy sumatriptan without prescription imitrex 50mg pill levofloxacin oral
buy cheap zofran spironolactone for sale spironolactone 100mg generic
buy generic dutasteride order zantac 300mg generic zantac for sale online
von willebrand ddavp surgery
when to check depakote level
cozaar blood sugar
buspirone and citalopram
buy acillin medication buy penicillin medication cheap amoxicillin tablets
buy generic finasteride finasteride 5mg oral buy diflucan 100mg without prescription
purchase ciprofloxacin online cheap – order cephalexin 250mg buy augmentin 375mg for sale
ddavp overdose
depakote extended release dosage
cozaar adverse effects
does citalopram make you sleepy
buy flagyl 400mg without prescription – order amoxil without prescription azithromycin 500mg for sale
ciprofloxacin drug – order ciprofloxacin 500 mg pills erythromycin canada
diltiazem dosing
diclofenac vs naproxen
augmentin 5 or 7 days